How to Balance a Real Estate-Heavy Portfolio with Equities for Better Risk and Return

• by Katie Crawford
• 2 Comments

Why Your Real Estate Portfolio Needs Equities

If most of your wealth is tied up in rental properties, commercial buildings, or land, you’re not alone. Many investors build wealth through real estate because it feels tangible, generates steady income, and has historically held its value. But here’s the problem: real estate doesn’t move the same way as stocks. When interest rates climb, office vacancies rise, or local economies slow, your property values can drop - and you can’t sell quickly to cut losses. That’s where equities come in.

Adding stocks to your portfolio isn’t about abandoning real estate. It’s about balancing risk. Over the last 20 years, direct real estate has had a correlation of just 0.35 with the S&P 500. That means when stocks crash, your rentals might still be filling up. And when real estate slows - like it did from 2022 to 2023, with commercial values dropping 15-20% - your stock holdings can help cushion the blow.

The Real Estate Crisis That Made Diversification Essential

From late 2021 to early 2024, the commercial real estate market took a hard hit. Office vacancies hit 18.6% nationwide. Industrial properties? Still at 95% occupancy. Why? Because warehouses and data centers keep growing. Offices? Not so much. Zoom didn’t disappear - but hybrid work did. And lenders got nervous.

Banks started tightening loan terms under new Dodd-Frank rules. Cap rates on office buildings jumped to 6.1%, meaning buyers needed bigger discounts to make deals work. Meanwhile, industrial properties held cap rates around 4.2%. That’s a 1.9 percentage point gap - and it’s not going away. If your portfolio is 70% office space, you’re exposed. But if you’ve got 40% industrial, 30% multifamily, and 30% stocks? You’re weathering the storm.

How Much Real Estate Is Too Much?

There’s no magic number, but most experts agree: don’t go over 35% of your total portfolio in direct real estate. That’s the recommendation from Wealth Advisors’ 2024 Strategic Edge report. For a balanced portfolio, they suggest:

• 35% real estate (direct or REITs)
• 25% public equities
• 20% bonds or fixed income
• 10% private equity
• 10% other alternatives (infrastructure, commodities)

This mix isn’t about chasing the highest returns. It’s about smoothing out the ride. Vanguard’s simulations show portfolios sticking to this structure delivered 23% higher risk-adjusted returns from 2010 to 2023 than those overloaded with real estate.

And here’s the kicker: even within real estate, you need balance. Don’t put all your money in one city. Don’t bet everything on offices. A portfolio with 40% U.S. real estate, 30% Europe, and 30% Asia had 18% lower volatility than one focused only on the U.S. - even if the returns were slightly lower.

Equities as Your Liquidity Lifeline

Real estate is illiquid. Selling a building takes months. Finding a buyer? Even longer. Stocks? You can sell in minutes. That liquidity matters more than you think.

Imagine you need $200,000 for an emergency - your kid’s medical bill, a family business opportunity, or a tax bill. If your only assets are rental properties, you’re stuck. You might have to take a high-interest loan, sell at a discount, or delay a better investment. But if 25% of your portfolio is in public stocks? You can tap into that without touching your rentals.

And it’s not just about emergencies. Markets shift. When interest rates peaked in 2023, real estate prices fell. But tech stocks rebounded. If you had cash in equities, you could have bought more real estate at lower prices - without selling your properties.

REITs: The Bridge Between Real Estate and Stocks

Not all real estate exposure is the same. Direct property ownership gives you control - but also headaches. REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) let you own shares in real estate companies without managing tenants or maintenance.

Here’s why they’re powerful: REITs have a correlation of just 0.28 with the S&P 500 over the past decade. That’s lower than the 0.65 correlation between REITs and direct real estate. In plain terms: REITs act more like stocks, but they’re still tied to real estate fundamentals. That makes them perfect for bridging the gap.

For example, you can hold an industrial REIT like Prologis or a multifamily REIT like AvalonBay. These pay dividends (usually 3-5% annually) and trade like stocks. You get income, exposure to real estate, and liquidity - all in one.

Where to Put Your Money: Sectors That Work in 2025

Not all real estate is created equal. Here’s what’s working in 2025, based on CBRE and NCREIF data:

• Industrial (warehouses, data centers): 4.2% cap rate, 2.8% rent growth. Still in high demand.
• Multifamily (apartments): 4.8% cap rate, 3.1% rent growth. Always needed.
• Senior housing: 5.0% cap rate, 3.5% rent growth. Aging population = steady demand.
• Office: 6.1% cap rate, -1.2% rent growth. Avoid unless you’re buying deep discount.
• Retail: Mixed. Grocery-anchored centers doing fine. Malls? Not so much.

If you’re adding new properties, focus on industrial, multifamily, and senior housing. If you already own office space, consider selling or converting it. Don’t hold on hoping it’ll bounce back. The data says it won’t - not for years, if ever.

How to Start Balancing Without Selling Everything

You don’t need to liquidate your entire portfolio. Start small. Here’s a simple 3-step plan:

1. Assess your current mix. What percentage is in office? In one city? What’s your cash flow vs. appreciation focus?
2. Set your target. Aim for no more than 35% in real estate total. Split that into 60% core (stable income), 30% value-added (growth), and 10% opportunistic (high risk).
3. Rebalance gradually. Each time you get rental income, put 30-50% into a low-cost S&P 500 index fund. Use platforms like CrowdStreet or Fundrise to buy fractional real estate in new sectors without buying entire buildings.

Many investors use technology tools like CASAFARI to track property types across markets. Users report cutting research time by 40% and avoiding overexposure to weak sectors.

Watch Out for These Mistakes

Even smart investors mess this up. Here are the top three pitfalls:

• Overconcentration. 68% of investors who lost money in 2022-2023 had more than 50% of their portfolio in one market or one property type.
• Ignoring risk profiles. Value-added and opportunistic deals promise 15%+ returns - but 25% of them lost money. Stick to core and core-plus unless you’re experienced.
• Chasing past performance. Just because industrial did well last year doesn’t mean it will keep going. Rebalance annually.

And remember: not all managers are equal. The top quartile of value-added funds made 14.2% net returns from 2018-2023. The bottom quartile lost 3.7%. Your success depends on who you partner with - not just the asset class.

What Happens If You Do Nothing?

Real estate isn’t going away. But the market is changing. The global commercial real estate market shrank from $7.4 trillion in late 2021 to $6.2 trillion in early 2024. Meanwhile, public equities grew 23.5% in the same period.

If your portfolio is 80% real estate and 20% stocks, you’re falling behind. You’re not just missing growth - you’re increasing your risk. When the next recession hits, you won’t have the liquidity to buy more assets at low prices. You’ll be forced to sell under pressure.

Equity balancing isn’t about giving up real estate. It’s about making it stronger. It’s about protecting what you’ve built - and setting yourself up to grow again.