Open Finance vs. Open Banking: How the Scope Is Expanding

When you link your bank account to a budgeting app like Mint or YNAB, you’re using open banking. But what happens when that same app can also see your investment portfolio, your crypto wallet, your small business loan, and your retirement account? That’s open finance-and it’s already starting to change how we manage money.

What Is Open Banking?

Open banking started as a regulatory fix, not a tech dream. In Europe, the Payment Services Directive 2 (PSD2), which took full effect in September 2019, forced banks to let customers share their transaction data with third-party apps-only if the customer said yes. No more screenshots of bank statements. No more logging into five different apps just to track spending.

Today, if you’re in the UK, EU, Australia, or Brazil, open banking is legally defined. Your bank must provide secure, standardized APIs so apps like Revolut, Monzo, or even your mortgage lender can access your checking and savings account data. The goal? Give you more control. You decide who sees what, and you can revoke access anytime.

Common uses? Connecting your accounts to a spending tracker. Automatically categorizing your expenses. Getting a better loan offer because a lender can see your full cash flow-not just your last pay stub. These are real, everyday benefits. But they’re limited. Open banking only covers payment accounts: checking, savings, and sometimes debit cards. It doesn’t touch your stocks, your insurance, or your crypto.

What Is Open Finance?

Open finance is open banking’s bigger, bolder sibling. It doesn’t stop at your bank account. It pulls in everything financial: investment accounts, pensions, insurance policies, small business loans, credit cards, even cryptocurrency wallets.

Imagine a single dashboard that shows you how much you’ve saved, how your ETFs are performing, what your life insurance payout would be if something happened, and how much you owe on your business line of credit-all updated in real time. That’s open finance. And it’s not science fiction. Companies like Akoya and Truelayer are already building it.

The key difference? Open banking is about access to your transaction history. Open finance is about access to your entire financial life. It lets apps not just read your data, but act on it. Need to automatically move $200 from your savings to your brokerage account every payday? Open finance can do that. Want to compare your insurance premiums across providers using your real spending habits? Open finance makes it possible.

Why the Scope Is Expanding

People don’t live in silos. Your money doesn’t stay in one place. You might save in a high-yield account, invest in ETFs through Robinhood, pay for groceries with a rewards credit card, and run a side business with a separate merchant account. But most financial tools still treat each account like a separate island.

Open finance fixes that. It’s not just about convenience-it’s about accuracy. When lenders or advisors only see part of your picture, they make worse decisions. A bank might deny you a mortgage because it doesn’t know you have $15,000 in a brokerage account. A robo-advisor might recommend aggressive investing because it doesn’t know you’re also paying off $50,000 in student loans.

The European Commission recognized this in early 2023. After a public consultation, they started laying the groundwork for what could become PSD3-the next step after PSD2. PSD3 wouldn’t just regulate bank data sharing. It would extend those rules to investments, pensions, and insurance. That’s the real shift: from banking as the center of your finances, to finance as the whole system.

In the U.S. and Canada, there’s no federal law mandating open banking yet. But the market is moving anyway. Fintechs are building APIs that connect to more than just banks. Plaid, for example, already pulls data from over 12,000 financial institutions-including brokerage firms and crypto exchanges. It’s not regulated the same way as in Europe, but it’s happening.

How It Works: The Four Steps

Whether it’s open banking or open finance, the process is the same:

1. Consent: You log into your bank or investment provider through a third-party app and click “Allow.” No passwords are shared. You’re granting permission, not handing over your login.
2. API Access: The app uses a secure, encrypted connection (usually RESTful APIs) to request data directly from your financial institution.
3. Data Usage: The app uses your data to provide a service-aggregating accounts, spotting spending trends, suggesting better rates, or automating transfers.
4. Security: Everything is encrypted. Access tokens expire. You can revoke permission at any time. No one is hacking your account-they’re just asking for a peek, and you’re the one holding the key.

This isn’t risky if done right. The same security standards used by banks to protect your money are used to protect your data. And because you control the access, you’re not handing over your password to some sketchy app.

Where It’s Headed: Regulatory Shifts and Real-World Impact

Right now, open banking is the law in the EU, UK, Australia, and Brazil. Open finance? It’s still mostly voluntary-or in early pilot stages. Israel is one of the few countries building specific open finance laws. The EU is pushing hard. The European Commission’s consultation closed in early 2023, and experts expect legislation to follow in 2025 or 2026.

But regulation isn’t the only driver. Consumers are. A 2023 OECD report found that people in countries with open banking are more likely to use financial apps-and more likely to trust them. That trust is the foundation for open finance. If you’re comfortable letting a budgeting app see your bank account, you might be ready to let it see your 401(k) too.

And the benefits aren’t just personal. Businesses win too. A small business owner can get a loan faster because a lender can see their real revenue stream across bank accounts, PayPal, and Stripe. An insurance company can offer dynamic premiums based on your actual spending and savings habits, not just your credit score.

Open Banking vs. Open Finance: A Quick Comparison

Think of open banking as the foundation. Open finance is the whole house built on top of it.

What’s Next?

Open finance isn’t coming in five years-it’s already here, quietly. In the U.S., you can already use apps like Empower or Cleo that connect to your brokerage and crypto accounts. In Europe, platforms like Revolut and N26 are testing features that auto-allocate savings into investment funds based on your spending.

The next five years will see three big shifts:

• More data types: Insurance policies, pensions, and small business financials will be included.
• More automation: Apps won’t just show you your money-they’ll move it for you, based on rules you set.
• More regulation: The EU’s PSD3 will likely set the global standard. Other countries will follow.

And here’s the quiet truth: open finance isn’t about replacing banks. It’s about making them part of a bigger system. The banks that adapt will thrive. The ones that resist will become irrelevant.

Frequently Asked Questions